.png)
Beyond the Hype: Embracing the True Excitement of IPOs
Written by Katie Wham, CFA®
Initial public offerings (IPOs) often generate headlines and sometimes create hype. When a fast-growing company or a household brand announces a public listing, it can be exciting and may present a good opportunity. At Badgley Phelps, investing in innovation and high quality, growing businesses is in our DNA. Navigating changing markets for over 60 years has taught us that real long-term success isn't borne from chasing headlines or market hype—it comes from identifying truly generational businesses and understanding how they fit into your portfolio.
Deciding whether to invest in a newly listed company requires both optimism and high standards. To build a resilient portfolio, our research team emphasizes both quality and growth, and IPOs can play an important role in a diversified set of investments.
The Evolving Company Lifecycle
The path a company takes to a public market debut has shifted over the last few decades. In the 1980s and 1990s, younger companies routinely went public at an early stage to gain access to growth capital. Today, many companies are staying private much longer. Due in part to the massive influx of private capital, companies can afford to grow into a more mature business before going public. In fact, between 1980 and 2024, the average age of a company at its IPO more than doubled, from 6 years to 14 years (CNBC).
This means some firms are entering public markets with significantly greater scale, more established business models, and deeper historical data. For investors, this may matter.
-
Less Speculation: A modern IPO may look less like an early stage “bet” on a founder and more like an established operating company. However, for newly public companies the range of outcomes is still wide, which is both exciting and risky. Our team can help discern what’s hype versus opportunity.
-
Industry Context: Evaluating how the IPO compares to other established companies in similar areas, as well as considering the IPO in the context of its addressable market and growth potential, is part of the decision-making process. Sometimes, waiting to observe how the stock trades can be the smartest move.
-
Market Perspective: An experienced investment research and trading team can bring nuance and depth to an evaluation of pricing, demand, and market activity around the offering.
What We Look For: Management Excellence, Quality Growth, Agile Strategy
When evaluating a new listing, it is important to understand what is driving a compelling narrative. We look for management teams who demonstrate specific traits:
- Exceptional Capital Allocators: Leaders who know where to deploy dollars to generate the highest returns.
- Market Creators: Visionaries who don't just compete in existing industries, but can disrupt them. Excellent leaders can also predict and create demand, and build brand new markets from the ground up.
- Dynamic Adaptation: Companies may start in a very narrow, niche market but later prove they can navigate a constantly shifting business environment to scale into something massive.
- Competitive Moat: Teams who protect and grow sustainable competitive advantages that can’t easily be diminished tend to create value over time.
Evaluating an IPO is simultaneously an art and a science.
The science lies in the fundamental analysis and evaluation of cash flows, earnings growth, profit margins, and valuations relative to established peers. IPOs can often trade up significantly in the excitement of the debut, but then underperform as the initial thrill meets the reality of public market dynamics. An experienced investment team can discern when a company is priced attractively, and when it is overhyped.
The art lies in portfolio construction. The IPO should fit into your high quality diversified portfolio, complementing what you already own. Understanding the industry where the company currently operates and projecting the potential of what they can become requires both optimism and experience.
Our goal is to build a customized, balanced portfolio that capitalizes on these evolving opportunities without sacrificing financial security
Sidebar: Is Your Company Going Public?
Essential considerations for employees navigating an IPO.
If you are an employee at a company shifting from private to public, congratulations! This can be an incredibly rewarding milestone. However, watching your paper wealth turn into public—and potentially volatile—stock requires planning in order to achieve success.
- The Concentration Question: It is easy to become emotionally attached to your company's stock, but having a massive percentage of your net worth tied to a single, newly public firm exposes your net worth to volatility. Maintaining enough ownership to participate in the upside without putting your lifestyle and goals at risk requires a plan that takes into account your personal circumstances.
- Risk Management: Depending on lock-up periods and insider trading windows, there are sophisticated strategies that may help you manage the risk. Our team can recommend a strategy that fits your needs.
Excitement, Earned
Whether you are looking to add new listings to your investment mix or you hold equity in a company preparing for its market debut, we are here to guide you.
Because these topics are highly nuanced and dependent on your personal tax and financial circumstances, they are often best handled in conversation. We would love to bring our deep expertise in investment analysis and financial planning to your specific situation. Be in touch with our team here.
